told my mother today!!!!
suspect it may be simply they were living together and enumerator assumed they were married.
don't think other mary ann marriage is relevant at all. mary Ann had Elizabeth in 1865 so def still with T. Charlton then!!
my understanding is from my aunt (some while back) that the Charltons / Purvises were a very close family. Now we know why!!
Feel sorry for William (1863 my GGrandfather) who was brought up by Mary Anns parents the Gardners. Did Thomas Charlton refuse to allow him to live with his mother because of the situation although Elizabeth was with them?
they all lived pretty close - Percy main / Chirton area.

I love a good story - prob never know but its what makes this hobby so exciting don't you think.
BTW any ideas on William (abt 1815 - 1861)? as posted earlier. can't find him anywhere.
Diddy