William the shipper, according to his marriage doc, Jan 10 1894, St George Anglican Montreal, William Herring, bachelor, son of Charles James Herring of London and Mary Ridley his wife, married Mary Ellen Fox, spinster, daughter of John Fox of Connaught Ireland and Sara Donahue his wife.
At the 1911 census this Herring family is living at 50a Dominion Avenue. The wife seems to be using her maiden name somehow, which has been mistranscribed as Rox, and the 4 children are mistranscribed as Hersing.
In the 1913/1914 Lovell’s Montreal directory William Herring the shipper is living at 50a Blake. William Herring the blacksmith is living at 251 Hamilton.
Looking at a map, I see that Blake is in Montreal proper just on the edge of Atwater, a major road. Hamilton is in a completely different area, a couple of miles away and south of the Lachine Canal which cuts through the Island of Montreal. Usually relatives who arrive in a new country settle nearby to any family who are already there. I have heard that in Saint John, New Brunswick, you can tell which part of Ireland a family came from just by knowing what street they are living on.
So…no obvious connection between the two Williams.
Other Herrings: There is a JH Herring on Brock. Of all the streets the Montreal Herring families are living on, Brock is the nearest to Hamilton, also south of the Lachine Canal and just a few streets over.
I’ll post this now because it’s getting longwinded, but I’m still working on it. Like I don’t have any housework to do…
Cheers,
China