Thanks Carole,
Benjamin's occupation given on the marriage certificate was 'Collier'. I too have found no Scotish women marrying a Benjamin....this is a family "I think g-grandma was from Scotland" comment. The known facts are Father Benjamin, from S. Wales, Welsh speaking, went to USA, date of death.
I have found several Benjamins and Williams who might fit the bill, including people from Carmarthen and Swansea but the 'best fit' seems to be the folk from Aberdare. My BIG problem with them is the elder brother who went to the USA. There seems to be no record of him. If I could find an elder brother in this family, it would be MY family. I definately know William went to the USA...he told me himself (unless he was lying)
William married Margaret Alice Barr at the Church of St John the Baptist Atherton and in 1901 they were livng in Lancashire (Shackerley with Tyldesley)
Benoni