Two Hannah Reeds

[andreajs]

Hi

I am wondering if anyone out there can help me solve a riddle of two Hannah Reeds

My Hannah according to census was born between 1810 and 1812, she married George Hardy in 1832.
I found on the IGI a Hannah Reed bap 27 Jul 1812, parents Robert and Hannah ( t his ties in as Hannahs 1st son is named Robert)
Unfortunately for me there is also another Hannah Reid bap 5 May 1811 at Cliff Lane Prestbyterian in Whitby who's parents were also called Robert and Hannah......

Now the confusing bit,
there are definately two separate Hannahs, the other Hannah marries Jonathon Gray in 1835 and they also name their first son Robert.

I can only find one marriage in Whitby in 1801 of a Robert Reed to a Hannah Kirkman
In the 1841/51 and 61 census they seem to be living next door to the Grays

There are other Reed children bap at different churches in Whitby with Robert and Hannah as parents but no idea how to unravel them! Would be grateful for any suggestions?
What do people think of there being two daughters named Hannah as i know this isn't unheard of??

Sorry for  the garbled post but i'm having trouble thinking straight!
Thanks Andrea

[Shipwright23]

Whitby Prs St Marys
Death

Oct 12 Reed, John son Robert & Hannah (labourer) 1 year, Whitby
Aug 29  1814 Reed, Hannah, Whitby, infant
Oct 13  1815 Reed, Hannah, Whitby, 36yrs
Jan 7   1835 Reed, Robert, Whitby Cliff Lane, 65 yrs

Birth
Apr 12 1801 Reed, John son Robert & Hannah (labourer) born Mar 8th, Hawsker
Jul 27 1812 Reed, Hannah dau Robert & Hannah (farmer) born 25th, Cock mill

Marriage
May 18 1800 Robert Reed*, bachelor, labourer & Hannah Kirkham*, spinster, both of this parish, banns
Wit Hannah Barker, Edward Kenyon
Cur John Atkinson

Nov 19 1816 Robert Reed*, widower, labourer & Rachel Gibson*, spinster, both of this parish, banns
Wit Wm Fewster, John Calvert

Oct 21 1832 George Hardy, bachelor, cordwainer & Hannah Reed, spinster, both of this parish, banns
Wit George Smith, Ralph Greenbury

Jun 13 1835 Robert Reed, bachelor, mariner & Elizabeth Smith, spinster, both of this parish, licence
Wit Thomas Wilson, Dorothy Cooper, Mary Coulson, Joseph Coulson

Dec 13 1835 Jonathan Newton Gray, bachelor, tinner & brazier & Hannah Reed, spinster, both of this parish, licence
Wit James Hall, Hannah Hall

shipwright

[andreajs]

Wow
Thank you so much for this!!

Will need some time to digest all this.

Wonder if the Robert Reed marrying Rachel is my Hannahs father

Thanks again
Andrea