Hello BB
Sorry for delay in replying.
Re the whereabouts of Hugh Mackay in 1851, there is a Hugh Mackay age 27 from Tongue, working on the road gang at Overscaig. However I’m not convinced it’s your ancestor, the age is wrong and there are others within that age range.
Re Hugh Mackay’s mother:
I agree, different names for Hugh’s mother Ann, wife of William Mackay, are a puzzle, but IMHO it’s most likely that his second wife was Ann Manson.
The name ANN MANSON was used in two events in the OPR, these are solid – marrage 23 Mar. 1822 and baptism of 2nd son James 26 Dec. 1825.
It was quite common in Tongue at that time for women to use two surnames – sometimes they just used their husband’s surname, or perhaps they were illegitimate and used two surnames at whim.
So Ann Manson may also have used the name Mackay. Or perhaps her son Hugh had forgotten his mother’s maiden name, he had been away many years when he married in 1864.
As for the deaths of the other two children, James (1897) and Mackayina (1898), they were registered by Hugh Mackay, “sub-postmaster and woodcutter” in Coldbackie. He would have no personal knowledge of the family. Maybe he got it right (Manson) with James in 1897; as for (Clark) on Mackayina’s death registration, who knows??
When my parents married, my father gave the registrar his mother’s middle name instead of maiden surname – and the lady was actually at the wedding!
There was a family of Mansons in Coldbackie, and a larger extended family in Dalcharn five minutes away – unfortunately we can’t make connections.
Ann Manson and William Mackay both died before 1855 and no gravestone exists, so lost in the sands of time.
Regards
Mary Young
www.cmy.org.uk