Hi again
I should explain that I have been researching the Bankhead family history for over 25 years and my write up is now over 100 pages long (available in soft copy). The Bankhead/Hatfield/Antrim 1748 mystery is a very difficult one and has perplexed many researchers including myself. The likelyhood of finding answer is exceedingly low. There are an awful lot of S Carolina Bankhead descendants who would love to know the answer too. My notes sum it up. I attach two sections of it in reverse order in an attempt to make it easier to follow. The "Westward from S Carolina " referred to is an (unpublished) immense history of the American Bankheads of which I have an incomplete hard copy (long story)
" The records for 18th Century Antrim are very bleak indeed but the religious census of 1766 for Ahoghill survives. It throws up James #5 and Robert #1 Bankhead, dissenters. Robert has not previously appeared in Ulster as a family name but it was quite common in contemporary Ayrshire families. One wonders, albeit tentatively,if this is evidence of a fresh migration.
The family tree really begins to blossom in Ahoghill from 1800 onwards but there is an agonising generation gap between 1766 and that date. One odd occurrence is the will in 1795, recorded but again destroyed of a James #6 Bankhead in Tamnabroke. There are at least two possibilities here, is it near Kilrea on the east bank of the Bann or the quarterland near Glenarm ?
In "Westward from S Carolina" - the American family history, we find the following reference "James Bankhead spouse of Mary Hatfield, sailed from Belfast October 21 1767 for Charleston on board the Betty Gregg".
This James (#3 in Westward from S. Carolina) we shall designate #7. He was born in Ireland c 1748, or so the story goes. It is impossible to pin him down - is he a son of Hugh #3 or James #4 or even another appearance of James #5/"
and
" Towards Ahoghill
By 1740 however a Hugh #3 Bankhead was resident in Ahoghill Parish and James #4 Bankhead plus Samuel #1 Bankhead in the adjoining parish of Drummaul. James #4 appears in the minutes of the Ulster Synod of 1738 when as one of 30 heads of families and 12 young men they asked for and were granted disannexation from Drummaul and transference to Ahoghill. Quite why this happened is not revealed in the minutes. The name Samuel is largely peculiar to later families living at Ballybollen which is straddled by these two parishes and this would appear to be when the split occurred.
A very curious entry occurs in the Register of Death for Derry Cathedral:-
"Mr William Bankhead buried 15th November 1740". The Mr may suggest someone of substance as it was not used as freely in 1740 as it is today.
In about 1738 the birth occurred of the one Bankhead whom most family members have heard of regardless of any interest in genealogy. His birthplace and parentage remain pure speculation but the Rev John Bankhead who for some seventy years was associated with the parish of Ballycarry or Broadisland is a genealogists delight, having produced it is said some 22 children of whom 19 survived. Such a family deserves special treatment and is examined separately in Chapter --."
The earliest extant Bankhead family document dates from 1550s and is held by the National Archives here in Edinburgh
Regards
Matt