Gosh, you have given me food for thought here.
First, yes, sorry, Auchtermuchty is in Fife.
It's about 12 miles from Perth I think, and in the account book for a John Sutherland of Perth, who 'commissions goods from Rotterdam, London, Newcastle etc', he sells to 'John Suttie, Merchant in Auchtermuchty' 'lump sugar', 'powder sugar', loaf sugar, 'pearl-ashes', and 'hogsheads of lintseed (sic)'.
Pearl ashes was evidently potash.
The assumption that the burial in April 1837 was of a merchant is not mine. There is a report in the Fife Herald 30 MArch 1837 that says 'the body of John Suttie, late merchant'........ would scarcely have been recognised had it not been for a screw and some other articles in his pockets, having lain in the water for twelve weeks'
(My typing on my previous post seem to have missed the '1' off the number of weeks he'd been in the water - 12, not 2).
I can't see a burial on the Fife death index a John Suttie buried 25th April 1837 as you say in your post.
'John Suttie merchant' died 'Dec 1836, buried 24th MArch 1837' IS on the index.
Can you give me some links to the fact that a 'Carrier' was an officer of the law please.
I haven't heard this term before, and have looked briefly on Google to no avail.
You seem to know quite a lot about the Baird family. Have you done some research into them?
I was not aware that Ann, who married John Suttie, was the sister of Thomas Walker Baird.
Where did you find this information?
Thanks for your interest