great grandma

[DORAN54]

hi my great grandma 
Caroline Chivers
1838–1914
Birth 1838 • midsomer norton Somerset, England
Death 12 MARCH 1914 • broadwell lane end coleford now i have her with her husband thomas powell &family on the census's i also had what i thought was their marriage july 1859 monmouthshire but someone has sent me a message querying the marriage and that has started me to doubt myself?
their first child was born 1861going by baptisms can anyone see a differant marriage?please

[Milliepede]

Did they say why they were querying it?

[DORAN54]

yes he said she couldn't have been married to that thomas powell as he is on the 1861 census with his parents but if another marriage can be found  it is possible that they got married after the census and a child  could still be born same year if she was pregnant getting married

[Milliepede]

I see thanks.  Maybe Thomas was counted twice?  Once in his own household and his parents put him down as well 

Are the details for both Thomas' identical age birth place occupation etc

Thomas Powell 26 born West Dean Glos - can't clearly read occupation, could be coal miner
Caroline 23
James J 1 month

[Milliepede]

Is this the other Thomas?  If so he is younger and has a different occupation.

Abraham Powell 46
Maria 50
Thomas 21 son unmarried born West Dean occupation haulier

[Capetown]

GRO Index

POWELL James John -  1861 M Qtr, Monmouth Volume 11A Page 30

Mother's maiden name: CHIVERS

[DORAN54]

this one as the mary aged 6 is my grandma


Name
    Thomas Powell
Age
    42
Estimated Birth Year
    abt 1839
Relationship to Head
    Head
Spouse
    Caroline Powell
Gender
    Male
Where born
    West Dean, Gloucestershire, England
Civil parish
    West Dean
County/Island
    Gloucestershire
Country
    England
Marital Status
    Married
Occupation
    Coal Miner
Registration district
    Monmouth
ED, institution, or vessel
    21
Piece
    5225
Folio
    44
Page number
    22
Household Members

    NameAge
        NameThomas Powell
        Age42
        NameCaroline Powell
        Age40
        NameJames Powell
        Age20
        NameJohn Powell
        Age14
        NameWilliam Powell
        Age12
        NameJulia Powell
        Age9
        NameMary Powell
        Age6
        NameKate Powell
        Age1

[DORAN54]

GRO Index

POWELL James John -  1861 M Qtr, Monmouth Volume 11A Page 30

Mother's maiden name: CHIVERS

yes thats the james on 1881 age 20 i just posted

[Capetown]

Forest of Dean records

Baptism at Blakeney: 19 January 1851

James POWELL

parents: James (labourer) and Caroline, residence, Blakeney

Officating Minster: C BROOKSHANK