Oh so would it be worth my while to search if Charlotte Malone was Charlotte Oldfield which would account for the grandfather name being Oldfield . I will do that . I am getting very excited here . This could well be why no one has found George OLDFIELD in 1871 census as a child .. and he could quite likely say his grandfather was his father on his marriage cert . Quite the coincidence , whoo hoo , getting quite over excited . Thank you Fred .