It's a long shot but you could try the Call-Up Exemption Tribunals. A lot of ours (Stocksbridge WRY) don't name names but it is sometimes possible to work out who they were (a local auctioneer and valuer - there was only one), a butcher with four sons (worked that one out). Also, some of the records at the National Archives mention people by name, usually when they were appealing the tribunal's decision.
EDIT the tribunals were reported in the local newspapers