Hi,
You say:
His says his parents are a William and Elizabeth Fletcher (I don't know her maiden name)
But then you say:
Samuel Fletcher SR Parents:
Elizabeth FLETCHER (nee Fenton) age 53
Burial date 15 Oct 1843
abode South Leverton
That she is nee Fenton?
Presumably you are referring to the marriage in Sturton-Le-Steeple between a William Fletcher and Elizabeth Fenton on 7th March 1815?
This definitely seems like a possible marriage to me, taking into account that the first baptism to a William & Elizabeth Fletcher in South Leverton took place in August the same year. Important to note that he is down as a bachelor.
Unfortunately, there are several William Fletchers in the South Leverton area at the same time as yours - with Fletcher being one of the more common surnames (although not on the same level as Smith) - and the witnesses to that marriage do not share a surname with either party. Furthermore, none of William & Elizabeth's children (William, Sarah, John & Samuel) have particularly unusual names, which could have been useful.
I am wondering whether William was actually from Sturton-Le-Steeple, because there is a William baptised there to Thomas & Mary Fletcher on 31st December 1771. Can't see a burial for this man in Sturton-Le-Steeple, which could suggest he moved elsewhere. Slightly later than expected, but more in line with the fact that William had not been married previously (although he would still be an older groom). We are relying on the person who gave William's age at death in 1827 (assuming that is the correct burial) having reliable information, and that is not always the case. The informant may have only known that William was quite a bit older than his wife.
Just thought it was worth investigating.
Queenie
