Turnbull / Bonchesterbrige

[E.M. Wilson]

Yes, keep me posted as to what counts as a fact and what does not.

Tell me this, if W.B.W. a.k.a. Walter Bell a.k.a. Walter Wilson Elliot a.k.a Walter Wilson had a relationship with his father why was he not the heir apparent? Why did he receive nothing from the will?

I digress.  I have more facts that don't apparently count. Please show me the facts that do qualify that counter my argument.

"He" stated previously that W.B.W. a.k.a. Walter Bell a.k.a. Walter Wilson Elliot a.k.a Walter Wilson lived with the Hume family in Selkirk and apprenticed with them.  See Hume Census part 1 attached.

[E.M. Wilson]

Henry Hume Census document part 2

[E.M. Wilson]

I enjoyed this one:

“Have addressed letters to my father in Hawick and to my mother in Penrith – to Mr Lewis - Bookseller, John Brydon - Merchant, and Andrew Inglis - Mason. “

Why was “and to my mother in Penrith” left out of the previous post of this paragraph?

Where is the original undoctored page?

[E.M. Wilson]

"His" Bible refers to the Elliot Chidren, fathered by Robert Elliot born in Canonbie, Scotland in 1801. They're all from Canonbie, Scotland. See Robert Elliot's birth record attached. The whole family was born in Canonbie, Scotland just like W.B.W. a.k.a Walter Bell a.k.a Walter Wilson Elliot a.k.a. Walter Wilson.

[E.M. Wilson]

"Yawn"

Take a vitamin

[E.M. Wilson]

The Selkirk Master Baker by the common name of Walter Wilson ended up in Australia making more babies.  But the problem is how do you connect W.B.W., a.k.a. Walter Bell, a.k.a. Walter Wilson Elliot, a.k.a, Walter Wilson born in 1823, Canonbie Scotland to Walter Wilson Master Baker, 1851 in Selkirk.  28 years have passed.  Where did he pass them?

What was his name in Scotland BEFORE he was 28 years old?

Where did he live in Scotland, England  BEFORE he was 28 years old

These are basic questions that need to be answered.

I suspect that this illegitimate child grew up in the Guide Port Inn and the Crosskeys Inn and was tossed around like a hot potato.
 
So many discrepancies, now, the headstone has been changed. This is starting to look like a pantomime.

There is no traceability.  All of this information is being manipulated to fit a big guess that is a DEAD END.  Waste of time. What is eerie to me is the desperation the “he” has to be a real Wilson.

[majm]

EMW, re your post 

I enjoyed this one:

“Have addressed letters to my father in Hawick and to my mother in Penrith – to Mr Lewis - Bookseller, John Brydon - Merchant, and Andrew Inglis - Mason. “

Why was “and to my mother in Penrith” left out of the previous post of this paragraph?

Where is the original undoctored page?

Perhaps you could go back through this very long thread and using the quote button you could demonstrate your concerns.

JM

[majm]

The Selkirk Master Baker by the common name of Walter Wilson ended up in Australia making more babies.  But the problem is how do you connect W.B.W., a.k.a. Walter Bell, a.k.a. Walter Wilson Elliot, a.k.a, Walter Wilson born in 1823, Canonbie Scotland to Walter Wilson Master Baker, 1851 in Selkirk.  28 years have passed.  Where did he pass them?

What was his name in Scotland BEFORE he was 28 years old?

Where did he live in Scotland, England  BEFORE he was 28 years old

These are basic questions that need to be answered.

I suspect that this illegitimate child grew up in the Guide Port Inn and the Crosskeys Inn and was tossed around like a hot potato.
 
So many discrepancies, now, the headstone has been changed. This is starting to look like a pantomime.

There is no traceability.  All of this information is being manipulated to fit a big guess that is a DEAD END.  Waste of time. What is eerie to me is the desperation the “he” has to be a real Wilson.

All those questions you are now posing have likely been answered in earlier posts on this thread.   May I please suggest that the regular RootsChatters are volunteers, the owners of RootsChat do not require us to pay any subscriptions, and we are all expected to work co-operatively and collaboratively in an harmonous way.

I am turning off notifications for this thread.

JM

[E.M. Wilson]

I bring up these points because they have not been addressed. 

How do you connect a bastard born in 1823 in Canonbie, Scotland to a Master Baker in Selkirk in 1851 when neither of them have any record of where they've been for the past 28 years. 

They each need to be identified. 

How do you identify W.B.W. a.k.a Walter Bell a.k.a Walter Wilson Elliot a.k.a Walter Wilson after birth in 1823?

How do you identify the Master Baker in Selkirk showing up out of the blue in 1851 in Selkirk?

How do you connect these two people without any documentation? What is the documentation that connects these two events?

How much more harmonious can this be.  I am simply asking questions.  Don't feel any pressure.  I don't expect answers from you.  I will find them.