Anita:
I have George Caygill Metcalfe bap Jan 4th 1781 at Askrigg in my tree.
He was son of George Metcalfe 1743-1783 and Dorothy Caygill 1744-1838.
They were married at Askrigg June 14th 1770.
He married, Sept 1st 1825 at Askrigg,
Isabella Blades bap Oct 29th 1795 at Bainbridge.
She was dau of John Blades c1763-1854 and Ellen Wetherald c1764-1851.
They were married at Aysgarth June 27th 1784.
I have George Caygill Metcalfe and Isabella as having 5 children:
William b c1827 Bainbridge
George bap April 25th 1828, died May 13th 1828 at Bainbridge
Jane b c1830 Bainbridge
John b c1831 Bainbridge
George bap Feb 9th 1832 at Bainbridge.
Only 2 of those 5 children do I see in the Aysgarth PR's, the 2 Georges.
The rest come from various census returns.
There was , as you say, another William Metcalfe bap at Askrigg Jan 18 1824, son of Ann Metcalfe.
I had never made the link that the 2 Williams could in fact be the same person.
What brought the link to mind?