Wow guys, I am overwhelmed with your help. I would love to post a picture of Ernie if I knew how to. I have moved in with someone who's PC is very basically set up and not very IT literate, so am on a BIG learning curve. I hope to resolve it very soon and will do asap..
My info for Archibald is very sketchy from odd bits and bobs left by my maternal grandmother, these were her family. her grandmother's sister was Alice Mcnaught (nee Birchall/Burchall), have no name for husband.
Do have a James and Mab McNaught as witness' at Caroline Williams marriage, Alice's niece, her sister Caroline & John William's daughter....( are you still with me

they were the foster parents of Ernie, shown in 1881 census with them as a 'nursing child' !
Wow..not sure this helps you but it has me..

Denise