so where does this John Gibson and Elizabeth Miller marriage fit into the Gibson's (Anderson & William) who farmed at Burnhall in Coldingham in 1861 and 1871 census?
I have also traced a James GIBSON & Elizabeth at Heaghhead in the 1841 census, could they be the same couple, with Robert age 9, Mary 6, Margaret 4 & Isabella 1?
I cannot think that there were only two brothers in and around 1820, although I have a Thomas born in about 1829, all sons of DAVID GIBSON & ISABELLA RENTON.
I have a print from the O.P.R. marriages ref 738/00 0030 0196 Edrom, but the first entry on that page is for a James Gibson, hind Greenknowes and Beatrice Haig of Bunkle and their marriage ion 4th June 1830.
I think I can trace this family in the 1851 census, still in Bunkle and Preston with children
Joseph age 12, James 9, Margaret 6, Robert 4 and William 1
I will try and get hold of the 1861 census again for Bunkle & Preston and check.
any help would be useful, even if this data is incorrect, it eliminates some possibilities.
regards
Squirejay