Author Topic: trying to eliminate Susannah May  (Read 4677 times)

Offline nelwild

  • RootsChat Aristocrat
  • ******
  • Posts: 1,229
  • great grandmother Emma Jane.
    • View Profile
trying to eliminate Susannah May
« on: Saturday 13 November 10 20:23 GMT (UK) »
Hello,

im trying to establish what happened to my 3xg grandmother after 1871.

Her birth is registered in Thanet Susannah Sarah Paine 1852.

1861 Susannah Fain b1852 Margate.

1871 Susanah Warner b 1852 Kent (mothers new partners surname)

I cant find a death or a certain fate for her after 1871.

On subsequent census theres this:

1881 Susannah Hart born 1854 Margate(husband Albert)

1891 Susannah Hart born 1851 Margate.

1901 Susannah Hart born 1848 Margate.

1911 Susannah Hart born 1850 Margate.

I can find no marriage between an Albert Hart and any Susannah 1871-1911.The 1911 says married 40 years.

I ve looked at all the other Susannahs born c1850 Margate and eliminated all but one.
Shes Susannah May born june quart 1850.

1851 born 1850 Margate.

1861 born 1848 Margate.

I cant find what became of her after that.There isnt a local death.The only close death for a May in Thanet is Hannah Margaret in 1872 age 22.I know Hannah is sometimes used for Susannah,and i can see no Hannahs born 1850 in the area.Still a bit of a long shot though. The only marriage for a Susannah May in Thanet is dec quart 1879 to a John Stevens.

Looking at the 1881 and after i can see no evidence of a John Stevens married to a Susannah,certainly not connected to Thanet.

If anyone can help me establish what happened to Susannah May id be extremely grateful.If i can eliminate her then id be as sure as i can be without a marriage about what became of my 3xgreat-grandmother.

Maybe Susannah May married John Stevens then went abroad,so if anyone can see any evidence of that id be grateful.

Just any ideas or suggestions would be really welcome,

many thanks,

Nel.



Offline Zacktyr

  • RootsChat Veteran
  • *****
  • Posts: 732
  • My little paperweight!
    • View Profile
Re: trying to eliminate Susannah May
« Reply #1 on: Thursday 30 December 10 21:18 GMT (UK) »
Hi, Nel

I've just looked at your Paine/Hart posting and I am terribly confused by it.

You say:
Quote
im trying to establish what happened to my 3xg grandmother after 1871.

Her birth is registered in Thanet Susannah Sarah Paine 1852.


sounding quite assured that this is your lady.  But, then, you go on to say that you are trying to eliminate a Susannah May as a possibility.

I guess my question to you is, 'how are you so certain that Susannah Sarah Paine is your 3x great-grandmother and still be questioning if Susannah May is her, instead?'.

Can you clarify/simplify your query?

Sincerely,
Susan
CRN-Hocking
DVN-Bickle.Doble.Harris.Hill.Nrthcte
KEN-Austen.Bodeker.Collard.Dodd.Duncan.Eaton.Gregry.Hammnd.Herman.Hills.Hodgs.Ivysn.
James.Kemp.Milstd.Nut.Owlet.Ruck.Spilet.Terry.Tilby.Thmsn.Walker
SOM-Baker.Clatworthy.Linton.Parker.Smith.Stone.Twose
ABD-Barclay.Cruickshank.McKenzie.Shepherd.Club
LKS-Douglas.Gunn.Turner
MLN-Dicks/Dickson.Duff.Lindsay.Young
SHI-Bain.Cluness.Fordyce.Gray.Petrie
ASSISTANCE PROVIDED HERE IS FROM MY OWN DIRECT EXPERIENCE & NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS LEGAL ADVICE

Offline casalguidi

  • RootsChat Honorary
  • RootsChat Marquessate
  • *******
  • Posts: 14,447
    • View Profile
Re: trying to eliminate Susannah May
« Reply #2 on: Thursday 30 December 10 21:36 GMT (UK) »
Quote
I guess my question to you is, 'how are you so certain that Susannah Sarah Paine is your 3x great-grandmother and still be questioning if Susannah May is her, instead?'.

Both Susannah MAY and Susannah PAIN were born in the same area at the same time so Nelwild is trying to find the fate of Susannah MAY to see whether she could be the one who is later with Albert HART thus eliminating the possibility that Ms HART is actually Susannah PAIN if that makes sense.

Casalguidi :)
Census information is Crown Copyright http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk

Offline Zacktyr

  • RootsChat Veteran
  • *****
  • Posts: 732
  • My little paperweight!
    • View Profile
Re: trying to eliminate Susannah May
« Reply #3 on: Thursday 30 December 10 22:14 GMT (UK) »
Hi Casalguidi,

If you read Nel's initial query carefully, she clearly states that her 3x-great-grandmother - is - Susannah Sarah Paine born Thanet 1852.  So, I am wondering how she can be so certain of this entry and still be questioning the possibility of another individual.

Had Nel have said that she "thought" Susannah Sarah Paine was her lady, my request for a clarification of her query would not have been necessary.

I think she has taken a wrong turn somewhere and my query is to serve as a jog for Nel to recheck her findings and possibilities.  There is also a death in Elham District during December 1924 (vol. 2a, p. 1235) of HART,  Susannah  aged 74 which would put her birth circa 1850 - in line with that of the 1911 census, if that information is correct.  There is also a death of in Elham District during June 1928  (vol. 2a, p. 1491) of HART,  Albert  aged 72  which would put his birth circa 1856 and make for a strong contender for the husband.

Sincerely,
Susan 
CRN-Hocking
DVN-Bickle.Doble.Harris.Hill.Nrthcte
KEN-Austen.Bodeker.Collard.Dodd.Duncan.Eaton.Gregry.Hammnd.Herman.Hills.Hodgs.Ivysn.
James.Kemp.Milstd.Nut.Owlet.Ruck.Spilet.Terry.Tilby.Thmsn.Walker
SOM-Baker.Clatworthy.Linton.Parker.Smith.Stone.Twose
ABD-Barclay.Cruickshank.McKenzie.Shepherd.Club
LKS-Douglas.Gunn.Turner
MLN-Dicks/Dickson.Duff.Lindsay.Young
SHI-Bain.Cluness.Fordyce.Gray.Petrie
ASSISTANCE PROVIDED HERE IS FROM MY OWN DIRECT EXPERIENCE & NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS LEGAL ADVICE


Offline casalguidi

  • RootsChat Honorary
  • RootsChat Marquessate
  • *******
  • Posts: 14,447
    • View Profile
Re: trying to eliminate Susannah May
« Reply #4 on: Friday 31 December 10 07:59 GMT (UK) »
Quote
If you read Nel's initial query carefully

I did read the query carefully and it looks quite clear to me.

Susannah Sarah PAINE is Nel's ancestor last seen unmarried in 1871 ............... Nel is trying to find what became of her after 1871 ie. could she be the one with Albert HART or could that be Susannah MAY or even somebody else altogether.

Casalguidi :)
Census information is Crown Copyright http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk

Offline nelwild

  • RootsChat Aristocrat
  • ******
  • Posts: 1,229
  • great grandmother Emma Jane.
    • View Profile
Re: trying to eliminate Susannah May
« Reply #5 on: Friday 31 December 10 11:22 GMT (UK) »
Hello,

Casalguidis got it right.I had seen the two deaths in Elham,and given that they were living in Folkstone post-1871,thats probably them.But i still dont know if shes my 3xg grandmother.
The only other Susannah on pre-1871 census born circa right time and place that i havent eliminated is Susannah May,so if i can account for her it would make me more confident that i have the right one,

Nel.

Offline Zacktyr

  • RootsChat Veteran
  • *****
  • Posts: 732
  • My little paperweight!
    • View Profile
Re: trying to eliminate Susannah May
« Reply #6 on: Friday 31 December 10 14:46 GMT (UK) »
Hello Nel, Hello Casalguidi,

I am only trying to understand the logical sequence of events in the life of the 3x-ggp so that I may be of some real assistance in possibly identifying the correct solution to the problem.  It would do neither one of us any good if I, or anyone else, fills in the blanks in the sequence of life events with a plethora of assumptions, which will likely be proved wrong in the long run.  Educated hypothesis, however, will generally work to reveal the correct answers.  But to form an educated hypothesis one needs to have a full set of facts and logical sequences upon which to build.

So, there needs to be some logical sequence of events laid out tracking the trail from the 2x-ggp to the named 3x-ggp, Susannah Sarah PAINE - census, marriage certificate, and/or birth certificate of the 2x-ggp.

Nel, if you believe that your 3x-great-grandmother is Susannah Sarah PAINE then what is your proof of that circumstance that leads you from your 2x-ggp back to your 3x-ggp? 

Or, do you have a 2x-ggp who had been orphaned and you are attempting to move forward in time from a possible 3x-ggp to your 2x-ggp and just randomly settled on Susannah Sarah PAINE?

Do you have a birth certificate for your 2x-great-grandparent that specifies that Susannah Sarah PAINE is the next generation back?  What date was that child born?  Where was that child born?

Under what surname was the birth of your 2x-ggp registered?  PAINE, as would be the case if your 2x-ggp were illegitimate, or, under the surname of HART, or, under some other surname?

If you have no certain fate for Susannah Sarah PAINE following 1861 then how are you so certain that the 1871 entry of Susannah WARNER is your Susannah?  Were there other known siblings of your 3x-ggp still living in the household or was your 2x-ggp living in the WARNER household?

What leads do you have emanating from census and/or marriage or birth certificates of your 2x-ggp that could possibly help to trace the movements of your 3x-ggp over the ensuing years from the time of the birth of your 2x-ggp? For example, on the marriage of your 2x-ggp was there a witness whose name you didn't immediately recognize as being family, e.g. S. SMITH, who could possibly have been your 3x-ggp, Susannah Sarah PAINE.  Is there a neighbour on a census near to where your 2x-ggp was living who could have been a candidate for your 3x-ggp?

If you are able to shed a bit more light on this problem, I will take a look at it again to see, what, amongst my multitude of resources, could possibly hold the answer for you.

I would say that I wasn't the only confused by the lack of logical sequence in the original posting as when I had looked at it, it had received over 200 viewings but not one response. 

Sincerely,
Susan

P.S.  There is a Susannah Sarah PAIN who died at Greenwich District during June Qtr. 1862 (vol. 1d, p. 412) yet the Susannah Sarah PAINE whose birth is registered in Thanet 1852 is the only birth from 1845 to 1950 with that precise combination of Christian names under any surname spelling variant.  (I am ruling out the marriage at St. James Dec Qtr 1861 but there is a marriage Dec Qtr 1888 in Ipswich District of a Susannah Sarah PAYNE.  So you see, there are also many other possible outcomes for Susannah Sarah PAINE that took place farther field.  These are just a sampling of the possibilities.)
CRN-Hocking
DVN-Bickle.Doble.Harris.Hill.Nrthcte
KEN-Austen.Bodeker.Collard.Dodd.Duncan.Eaton.Gregry.Hammnd.Herman.Hills.Hodgs.Ivysn.
James.Kemp.Milstd.Nut.Owlet.Ruck.Spilet.Terry.Tilby.Thmsn.Walker
SOM-Baker.Clatworthy.Linton.Parker.Smith.Stone.Twose
ABD-Barclay.Cruickshank.McKenzie.Shepherd.Club
LKS-Douglas.Gunn.Turner
MLN-Dicks/Dickson.Duff.Lindsay.Young
SHI-Bain.Cluness.Fordyce.Gray.Petrie
ASSISTANCE PROVIDED HERE IS FROM MY OWN DIRECT EXPERIENCE & NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS LEGAL ADVICE

Offline nelwild

  • RootsChat Aristocrat
  • ******
  • Posts: 1,229
  • great grandmother Emma Jane.
    • View Profile
Re: trying to eliminate Susannah May
« Reply #7 on: Saturday 01 January 11 18:07 GMT (UK) »
Hello Zacktyr,

thanks for such a detailed response.Ill give you what i have,im afraid its a bit messy though,and not all that easy to follow.Ill start from the top and work down.

4xgreat grandparents Richard Holtum Pain/Jane Elizabeth Spain.

married Parish Church St.John,Margate on 12/10/1845.

Hes full age,labourer,living in Margate,father William Pain,mariner.

Shes minor,living Margate,father John Spain,labourer.

both made their mark with a cross,witnesses W H Spain/George Dixon.

the first confusion comes from 1841 census:

1841 in St Peters.

Richard Holton b1785 Kent.
Susannah(nee Pain) b1809 Kent.
Richard Pain b1828 Kent.
Bartholomew Pain b 1830 Kent.

class HO107 piece468 book19.

freebmd has baptisms for a Richard and Barth Hood Pain circa right dates and place,but as sons of Elizabeth Pain.

Richard Holtons wife Susannah Pain had a brother William b1790 St Peters and Elizabeth b1803.

So the baptism shows Richard as son of Elizabeth Pain,his marriage cert has him as son of William and the 1841 shows him with Richard Holton and Susannah Pain.

One possibility that occured to me is that they were the sons of William and a possible wife Elizabeth,but for some reason were raised by Richard and Susannah,possibly orphaned.

1851 census:

Richard H Pain b1825 Margate
Jane E b1826 Margate.
Richard J b1847 Margate.
George W b1848 St Peters.
John T b1850 Minster.

class HO107 piece 1629 folio287 page6.

I think Richard H died between 1851-61.Their are two deaths in Thanet,one in 1855,another in 1856.

1861 two entries:

In Thanet Workhouse:

Richard Fain(Pain) b1846 St Peters.deserted child.
John b1849 St Peters.deserted.
SUSANNA b1852 St Peters.deserted.

class RG9 piece524 folio71 page2

In a boarding house in Whitstable:

Jane Warman? b1828 Margate
Lenny? Payne b1855 Margate
Elizabeth Warner b1859 Whitstable.

class RG9 piece 524 folio71 page2.

I think Jane Warman could be a mis-transcription of Warner,although it definately looks like Warman on document.
Similarly,i think Lenny is Louisa Payne,although it definately looks like Lenny.

1871 census:

Thomas Warner b1834 Whitstable
Jane b1826 Margate
SUSANNAH born1852 Kent
Louisa born 1854 Kent
Sarah born 1870 Kent(listed as daughter,but shes grand-daughter)

class RG10 piece974 folio30 page15.

1881 census:

Thomas Bennett b1857 Whitstable
Louisa b1854 Minster,Kent.
Thomas Warner b1835 Seasalter,father-in-law.
Sarah b1870 Seasalter grand-child.

class RG11 piece965 folio61 p21

1891 census:

Louisa Payne b1852 Minster married
Sarah A b1870 Whitstable.
Emma J b1886 Whitstable.
Louisa E b1890 Whitstable.
Thomas Warner b1831 Whitstable.single.

class RG12 piece711 folio23 page11

1901 census:

Thomas W Warner b1834 Whitstable.
Louisa E Pain b1855 Margate daughter.

next door:

Sarah A Payne b1871 Whitstable.
Emma J b1886 Whitstable.
Lucy E b1889 Whitstable.
James T b1892 Whitstable.

class RG13 piece800 folio58 p27.

Theres a death for Thomas Warner sept quart 1904 Blean.

A possible death for Jane Payne sept 1879 Blean,although the age is a few years out.

My great-grandmother Emma Jane Pains birth cert shows her born 21/11/1885 Middle Wall,Seasalter,no father shown,mother Sarah Amelia Pain of Middle Wall,Seasalter,registered on 10th Dec.Shown on freebmd.

also on freebmd:

James Thomas Pain sept1892 blean 2a 852

Louisa(Lucy) Eliza june1889 blean 2a 841

her two siblings.

Sarah Amelias birth cert shows her born 14/03/1870 Whitstable,no father shown,mother Susannah Sarah Pain of Whitstable registered 24/03/1870.

Susannah Sarah Paine june quart 1852 Isle of Thanet 2a 543 on freebmd,dont have that cert yet.

Sarah Amelias death cert shows she died on 17/03/1941 at 2 Victoria St,Whitstable,age 71,surname Payne,widow of James Thomas Payne(seaman).The informant was her son James Thomas Payne.

Ive got Louisas marriage cert to Arthur Little on 26/08/1908 and she gives her father as Thomas Payne(deceased) farmer.

My great grandmother Emma Jane married my great grandfather Nelson Camburn on 05/06/1908 Whitstable Parish Church,no father shown for her.

She herself had an illigitimate daughter Margaret(Meg) reg june quart 1903 Blean.We dont know who her father was.She married Sidney Kay dec quart 1904 blean.They had about 10 children and lived their married life in London,where he was from.I believe most of them married around the West Ham/Romford area.

None of all this is helped by the fact that g grandmother never talked about her past or family,and ive found very few people on GenesReunited or other sites who are researching them,none in fact,apart from one relative of Sidney Kay.

Ive really gone on here,but if you or anyone else can dissect what ive got,add to it or take from it,id appreciate for anything at all.

Thanks to everyone whos helped me on this,im reallt grateful,

Nel.

 




 







Offline Zacktyr

  • RootsChat Veteran
  • *****
  • Posts: 732
  • My little paperweight!
    • View Profile
Re: trying to eliminate Susannah May
« Reply #8 on: Sunday 02 January 11 16:20 GMT (UK) »
Hi, Nel,

Many thanks for your informative reply.  I've gone through and charted the information and will have a really good look through it and my resources for you.  I have to get breakfast on the table at the moment, but will definitely get back to you before the day's end - I'm on EST in Ontario, Canada.

I did find your earlier two postings on this problem the first of which did give me a bit more information to work with concerning the possible connection to HART but still no joy coming from that one:

http://www.rootschat.com/forum/index.php/topic,459097.0.html

As well as your posting in an effort to eliminate Susanna MAY:

http://www.rootschat.com/forum/index.php/topic,459786.0.html

I will write again after I have had a chance to pound to books, so to speak, for you.  Here's to hoping we'll get it sorted for you. :)

Sincerely,
Susan

CRN-Hocking
DVN-Bickle.Doble.Harris.Hill.Nrthcte
KEN-Austen.Bodeker.Collard.Dodd.Duncan.Eaton.Gregry.Hammnd.Herman.Hills.Hodgs.Ivysn.
James.Kemp.Milstd.Nut.Owlet.Ruck.Spilet.Terry.Tilby.Thmsn.Walker
SOM-Baker.Clatworthy.Linton.Parker.Smith.Stone.Twose
ABD-Barclay.Cruickshank.McKenzie.Shepherd.Club
LKS-Douglas.Gunn.Turner
MLN-Dicks/Dickson.Duff.Lindsay.Young
SHI-Bain.Cluness.Fordyce.Gray.Petrie
ASSISTANCE PROVIDED HERE IS FROM MY OWN DIRECT EXPERIENCE & NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS LEGAL ADVICE