« Reply #18 on: Sunday 09 August 15 00:21 BST (UK) »
Thanks for the feedback about Elspeth Renwick, Bev. It's sometimes worth widening the focus from direct ancestors to siblings and aunts/uncles/cousins - I've found many a relative hiding with the in-laws!

Also, the recurrence of names and occupations, maybe in different branches of a family, often suggests connections, however remote.
As regards Tancred, he was not only an historian but also a good storyteller. He relied on the documentary evidence available to him (no internet in those days, of course) and the long - and occasionally dodgy - memories of local people. I remember reading some analyses of his work by a couple of distant Lorrain cousins of mine: one, a very well-known professor in his day who had taken the trouble to contact Tancred's widow, and the other, a semi-professional genealogist. Both concluded that some of his assertions about the Lorrain family heritage were probably a little wide of the mark. If that's true of my family, which is fairly well documented at times, it will be true of other families.
Regards
Ian
Iandj
Dumfriesshire: Martin, Lorrain(e), Smart, Muir
Roxburghshire, Selkirkshire: Lorrain, Turnbull, Riddell, Elliot(t), Ker(r), Scott
Lancashire, Cheshire: Johnston, Rutter, Barrow
Ayrshire, Lanarkshire: Jamieson, Glasgow, Thomson, Riddet, Blair
Clackmannan, Fife, Stirling: Simpson, Kirk, Stein, Pryde, Penman, Hempseed, Bauchop
Kincardineshire: Craig, Stewart