Thank you yes her father was Benjamin so this is correct. I have 2 possible fathers for John Edward - the one I have researched John b 1843 and the new possible William b 1828. The reason I'm now doubting is he was always known in the family as John Edward and he had a son , grandsons, great grandsons all called John Edward. The reason I had researched John was because I had been given a marriage cert for his father John so had looked for MMN. I am usually on these things but this was overlooked x