Yesterday I received a copy of a book entitled, "Early History of the Welsh in the Proscairon District of Wisconsin" by Daniel Williams (copyright 1894).
I immediately began reading it, and although I'd heard from others about the Roberts-Daniel relationships discussed within the pages, this was the first time I actually got to see it for myself.
I cannot tell you how cool it is to actually have documented interviews and commentary attributed to the ancestors I have been seeking information on for over a dozen years. Before, I had names and dates on a piece of paper, but reading actual quotes and stories told by my great great grandfather John Robert Daniel and others gives life and personality to those names.
As my peers in Wales continue to uncover new names and possible connections to my family tree I can now add some form of verification to what we've been discussing. While there is much we still do not know or cannot verify, I think it is important that we do not lose sight of what can be fairly relied upon with a good deal of conviction. That having been said, the pages of the book I've read thus far have these details to share:
Reverend Thomas Hugh Roberts
Reverend Thomas Hugh Roberts (1824-1880) is quoted on page 20 as referring to John Daniel as "my uncle." It has been repeatedly documented in various biographies and online trees that Thomas Hugh Roberts was the son of Hugh Roberts (1788-1865).
Hugh "Huw" Roberts
Hugh Roberts (1788-1865) is mentioned extensively in this publication. He gives a personal account of his life in which he states that at the age of 15 his parents moved the family from Braichwen to Blaen Y Cae (this personal account would seem to refute the claims on some trees that he was born at Blaen y Cae). He further states that his parents joined the congregation at Blaenrug Chapel. He was wed to Mary Jones, who has been linked (at birth) to Tan-y-Buarth, Llanddeiniolen. Hugh was about 60 years of age at the time he brought his family to the United States. The home they left behind on the voyage was recorded as Tan-y-Buarth, Llanddeiniolen. It has been written in various resources that Hugh Roberts was a relative of Jane Roberts-Daniel.
Thomas Robert Roberts
Thomas Robert Roberts (1826-1912) was a younger, half-brother to Hugh Roberts. While Hugh was a product of the first marriage of Robert Roberts to Mary Williams, Thomas was a product of his second marriage, to Cathrine Foulkes. In the publication I now have in my possession it is recorded that Thomas Robert Roberts was an uncle to John Robert Daniel, son of John and Jane Daniel. As Foulk Roberts was Thomas' brother, that would make Foulk an uncle to John Robert Daniel, as well.
Following these relationships as described, it is also plain to see that Jane Roberts was in fact a first cousin of Foulk and Thomas and Hugh Roberts, meaning she had to have been born to a brother of their father, Robert Roberts (1752-1832).
What has developed here is you can see how the generations stack up, whom is a part of each generation, and how the Daniel and Roberts families are tied to each other, as follows:
Generation 1
Robert Roberts (1752-1832)
Generation 2 (all cousins)
Hugh Roberts (1788-1865) - His son by first wife
Thomas Robert Roberts (1826-1912) - His son by second wife
Foulk Robert Roberts (1820-1908) - His son by second wife
Jane Daniel nee: Roberts (1786-1872) - Niece to Robert Roberts
John Daniel (1791-1859) - Jane's husband, referred to as "uncle" of Thomas Roberts, generation 3
Generation 3
Reverend Thomas Hugh Roberts (1824-1880) - Son of Hugh, referred to John Daniel as "uncle"
Reverend John Robert Daniel (1826-1898) - Son of John and Jane Daniel, referred to Thomas Roberts of Generation 2 as an uncle
There has been much written about the ancestral relationships and families of these people back in Wales, with many unanswered questions and mysteries yet to be resolved, but regardless, what has emerged to me from the pages of this book is a much clearer understanding of the relationships between these people once they set foot in the United States, and it is clear to me that despite what questions remain about her origins, Jane Roberts was in fact a niece of Robert Roberts, therefore a daughter of one of his brothers, whether that was John Roberts (b. 1765) or whomever. Taking it one step further, Jane would be the granddaughter of Robert John Evan Roberts and his wife, Jane Jones.